Carrie White (Carrie - 1976)
Susan Bradley (Kiss of the Tarantula - 1976)
Jennifer Baylor (Jennifer - 1978)
Rachel Lang (The Rage: Carrie 2 - 1999)
Carrie White (Carrie - 2002)
Carrie White (Carrie - 2013)
It's a tough call, but I think I'd have to go with Rachel. There are no wrong answers though, so defend your choice in the comments section below.
I write books about horror movies. The least you could do is buy them.